Raising the alarm on Islamofascism, one column at a time.

Know more →
US Politics

Alter or Abolish? How America Turned a Revolution into a Constitution

In 1776, the right to overthrow a government was a founding principle. By 1787, it had become a problem to be managed.

In January 1787, a column of debt-ridden farmers marched on the federal arsenal at Springfield, Massachusetts. Their leader, Daniel Shays, was a Revolutionary War veteran. State militia scattered the column and killed four of the marchers. The rebellion was over within weeks, but the alarm it set off was not.

The irony was hard to miss. Eleven years earlier, the Declaration of Independence had declared that when a government becomes destructive of the people's rights, "it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it." The idea came from John Locke, who argued in his Second Treatise that government rests on the consent of the governed. Now men who had made that argument against a king were watching their neighbors make it against them.

That summer, fifty-five delegates met in Philadelphia to answer a hard question: how do you build a lasting government on a founding act of rebellion?

The Founders Disagreed About the Danger

Not everyone panicked. Writing from Paris, Thomas Jefferson shrugged that "a little rebellion now and then is a good thing." George Washington, at home in Virginia, saw it differently. He feared the young republic could slip into disorder, and the news helped pull him out of retirement to preside over the convention.

The Constitution that resulted opens with "We the People." The phrase matters. The Framers did not deny popular sovereignty. They redirected it, turning a right once exercised with muskets into one exercised through procedure.

Four Safeguards, Two Jobs

The system they built does two different things. Two features let the people change their government. Two keep any government from becoming unchangeable or unchecked.

Channels for change

  • Regular elections. Voters can remove presidents and legislators on a fixed schedule, with no bloodshed and no collapse of the state.
  • Article V amendments. Two-thirds of Congress, or a convention called by two-thirds of the states, can propose changes, and three-fourths of the states must ratify them. The bar is high on purpose. It has been cleared only twenty-seven times.

Limits on power

  • Separation of powers. Splitting authority among Congress, the presidency, and the courts means no single branch can act alone.
  • Judicial review. Courts can strike down laws and actions that break the Constitution, giving citizens a way to challenge power without leaving the legal system.

Notice what is missing. Nothing in this design mentions the right to rebel. The right was not erased so much as replaced, with a promise that peaceful means would remain open.

The First Test: Whiskey and Law

The new government faced that question early. In 1794, farmers in western Pennsylvania resisted a federal excise tax on whiskey, in some cases attacking tax collectors. Washington responded by leading a militia force of roughly thirteen thousand men toward the region, and the protest dissolved before a major battle.

The message was deliberate. Under the Constitution, grievance had legitimate outlets, and armed resistance was not one of them.

Where the Law Draws the Line Today

Federal law still reflects that message. The Smith Act, now codified at 18 U.S.C. § 2385, makes it a crime to knowingly advocate overthrowing the U.S. government by force.

In practice, though, the First Amendment has narrowed that law considerably. In Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), the Supreme Court overturned the conviction of a Ku Klux Klan leader and set a demanding test. Even radical advocacy is protected unless it is directed at inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to produce it. Under that standard, the Smith Act's advocacy provisions are hard to enforce as written. Violence itself remains a crime. Talking about revolution, in most cases, does not.

Two Rival Readings of "We the People"

Americans still disagree about where legitimate resistance ends and lawlessness begins. Two traditions in particular claim the Founders' legacy.

The Constitutional Compact View

In this reading, the Constitution fulfilled the Revolution rather than betraying it. In his 1838 Lyceum Address, a young Abraham Lincoln, shaken by recent mob violence, urged that "reverence for the laws" become the nation's "political religion." On this view, popular sovereignty lives in the ballot box, in peaceful protest and civil disobedience, and in the courts. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s 1963 "Letter from Birmingham Jail" is often cited as the model: breaking a law openly, accepting the penalty, and appealing to the nation's conscience. Force, defenders argue, does not protect liberty. It silences fellow citizens.

The Citizen Vigilance View

A competing tradition reads the Constitution as a leash on the state, not a surrender of popular power. Its supporters point to Jefferson's famous remark that the tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time, and to the Second Amendment, which James Madison, in Federalist No. 46, tied to the idea that an armed citizenry could check a government's ambitions. Mainstream voices in this camp reject unlawful violence. Their emphasis falls on vigilance: an informed, skeptical public is the final safeguard against abuse.

Critics of this view respond that Jefferson's rhetoric came before the Constitution's peaceful remedies existed, and that appeals to armed resistance now risk undermining the very system that makes dissent safe.

Living with the Tension

The Framers never resolved this disagreement, and they did not try to. They built a system where both instincts must operate in plain view. Citizens may protest, organize, and dissent loudly. But the way to change the government runs through elections, amendments, and the courts.

That bargain is the quiet achievement of 1787. It asked Americans to guard their freedom without tearing down the house that shelters it, and more than two centuries later, they are still arguing about how to keep that promise.

Sources and Further Reading

  • The Declaration of Independence (1776) and the U.S. Constitution, Article V
  • Thomas Jefferson, letter to James Madison, January 30, 1787
  • Thomas Jefferson, letter to William Stephens Smith, November 13, 1787
  • MLK Jr.’s Letter from Birmingham Jail (1963)
  • Abraham Lincoln, Address to the Young Men's Lyceum of Springfield (1838)
  • Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969)
  • Federalist No. 46 (James Madison)
  • Anthony King, The Founding Fathers v. the People (Harvard University Press, 2012)
Amil Imani

Read more about Amil Imani →